Top 5 of the year

[Deleted User] · 13/12/04 - 21:56

What is everyone's top 5 films of the year?

Mine are:

1- Collateral
2- I, Robot
3- Man on Fire
4- Kill Bill 2
5- The Village

[Deleted User] · 13/12/04 - 22:18

pulp fiction
kill bill 1
matrix (the first one the other 2 were crap)
finding nemo
resivoir dogs

emzy.c. · 13/12/04 - 22:50

Pirates of the Caribbean
A Shark Tale
Peter Pan 2004

hmm, cant remember any others from this year

oh yea HP3

[Deleted User] · 14/12/04 - 01:09

* Shrek 2
* Finding Neverland
* Bridget Jones
* The Incredibles.

That's all I can remember from this year, although I'm sure there must be some good ones I've left out: wasn't impressed with HP3 & I'm sure Pirates of the Caribbean was last year?

Ratinho · 14/12/04 - 09:32

steven21 wrote:

What is everyone's top 5 films of the year?

Mine are:

1- Collateral
2- I, Robot
3- Man on Fire
4- Kill Bill 2
5- The Village

You're kidding, right? :rolleyes:

Erm, not much around of any quality this year. Saw was very good. Spiderman 2 was ok. More attempts at 'blockbusters' that were inevitably going to be sh*t to be honest. Harry Potter, Troy, yada yada yada.

And I wasn't aware Reservoir Dogs, Pulp Fiction and The Matrix came out this year.

[Deleted User] · 14/12/04 - 10:12

1, Finding Neverland
2, The Incredibles
3, Lost in Translation
4, Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind
5, Troy

[Deleted User] · 14/12/04 - 10:31

Can't put up a Top 5, haven't seen enough decent films for that (can't imagine putting up Troy :rolleyes: , for example, on such a list)

La mala educación is probably the best film I've seen this year, so it's definitely the number one among the awfuls and tolerables I've seen

Worth mention among the awfuls and tolerables: De-Lovely (although it was fairly strange :rolleyes: )

Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban was a lot better film than the awful first two but it's certainly not good enough to be listed in any top 5.

And LOTR The Return of the King gets a special mention here although technically it's of course not a film of 2004, but as I first saw it on 31 Dec 2003 and for a second time in January this year, it features on my lists for 2004 rather than for 2003.

[Deleted User] · 14/12/04 - 10:39

Lost in Translation. Bill Murray's finest hour (and he's had some other good ones up 'til now. Scarlett Johansson smoulders, and her performance with Murray is truly execptional.

Kill Bill Vol 2. Unlike many, for met this was the better of the two. Darryl Hannah and Michael Madsen were class, but Carradine and Thurman were in a league of their own. As always, Tarrantino's script was flawless.

Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind. Kaufman never fails to dissapoint, a wonderfully weird, touching and funny picture. Carrey was perfectly suited to the lead role and Winslet, who isn't someone I rated, was very good. Dunst and Wood provided unexpected, but very good backup roles.

Shaun of the Ded. Just bloody funny. Simon Pegg is a genius.

not sure if it was this year or last, but Alex Cox's 'Revenger's Tradgedy' was amazing. Christopher Eccleston and Eddie Izzard gave superb performances with one of the smartest scipts i've ever heard.

[Deleted User] · 14/12/04 - 12:13

maels wrote:

Can't put up a Top 5, haven't seen enough decent films for that (can't imagine putting up Troy :rolleyes: , for example, on such a list)

.

tee hee

I only put Troy down because I went expecting to see the worst film ever and it wasn't THAT bad. Mark my words - it's a cult classic!! The bit when Sean Bean is looking at the carving of a wooden horse then does that 'hmmmmm, I have a plan face'.... marvellous. If you want my serious contender for 5th place, I really enjoyed HP3, but I've a feeling Garden State will be in there after I've seen it tomorrow!!

PS - I hate happing endings too. I never watch the last ten mins of when H met S

Jackassfan · 14/12/04 - 12:23

1, Man on fire
2, The butterfly effect
3, Eternal sunshine of the spotless mind
4, Monster
5, Finding neverland

[Deleted User] · 14/12/04 - 12:36

anneonholiday wrote:

tee hee

I only put Troy down because I went expecting to see the worst film ever and it wasn't THAT bad. Mark my words - it's a cult classic!!

Lol

I had heard so much bad stuff about Troy before I went to see it that my expectations were pretty low anyway - it wasn't quite that bad. But I'd have to ignore a lot to put it down as one of the best films I've seen this year. But it looks like I've only seen pretty crappy films this year anyway so who cares :rolleyes:

Ratinho · 14/12/04 - 14:58

Right, I went away to think about what i'd seen, and I return with a genuine top 5:

5. The Butterfly Effect
4. Monster
3. Lost in Translation
2. Saw
1. Shaun of the Dead

Ahhhhhh! He's got a bloody arm off!

[Deleted User] · 14/12/04 - 15:41

Clapton=God wrote:

pulp fiction
kill bill 1
matrix (the first one the other 2 were crap)
finding nemo
resivoir dogs

none of these were out in 2004.

[Deleted User] · 14/12/04 - 17:14

Ratinho wrote:

And I wasn't aware Reservoir Dogs, Pulp Fiction and The Matrix came out this year.

sorry i misread the post.
my favorite ones from this year are (in no particular order):
1) kill bill
2) spiderman 2
3) incredibles
4) lotr 3
5) shaun of the dead

[Deleted User] · 15/12/04 - 07:55

Spiderman 2
Lost in Translation
Team America
LOTR3
The Incredibles

[Deleted User] · 15/12/04 - 11:25

1- lotr 3
2- I, Robot
3- Kill Bill 1
4- Kill Bill 2
5- Shrek 2

[Deleted User] · 15/12/04 - 14:33

Top 5 film this year are

1 - Beyond the Sea
2 - Bridget Jones - Edge of Reason
3 - Shrek 2
4 - The Day After Tomorrow
5 - I Robot

[Deleted User] · 15/12/04 - 16:03

In no particular order at all:

Garden State
Finding Neverland
Bad Santa
The Incredibles
Shrek 2

The other 5 runners up

Lost In Translation
Capturing The Freidmans
School Of Rock
Saved
Dodgeball

[Deleted User] · 15/12/04 - 19:09

No order in particular:

Shaun Of The Dead
Dodgeball: A True Underdog Story
Garden State
Lost In Translation (or was that 2003? Can't remember now...)
Fahrenheit 9/11

swellybro · 15/12/04 - 20:41

1) Collateral
2) The Incredibles
3) Fahrenheit 9/11
4) Sipderman 2
5) The Bourne Supremacy

[Deleted User] · 15/12/04 - 21:35

1)Napoleon Dynamite (funniest film of the year)
2)Bad Santa
3)School Of Rock
4) The Butterfly Effect
5)Dodgeball

Vannay · 15/12/04 - 22:26

Mine are:

shuan of the dead
man on fire
the bourne movie
garden state
Overnight

prob think of a few more but at this time those....do it

[Deleted User] · 16/12/04 - 08:59

anneonholiday wrote:

1, Finding Neverland
2, The Incredibles
3, Lost in Translation
4, Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind
5, Troy

ok , new entry at number 3, Garden State, shifting the others down and loosing Troy...

[Deleted User] · 16/12/04 - 16:02

1. Lost in Translation
2. Shuan of The Dead
3. Oldboy
4. Incredibles
5. Eternal sunshine of the spotless mind

[Deleted User] · 18/12/04 - 17:20

1. Bridget Jones : Edge of reason
2. Thunderbirds
3. School Of Rock
4. Troy
5. The Forgotten

[Deleted User] · 19/12/04 - 09:37

1. Phantom of the Opera
2. Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind
3. Troy (shhh... dont tell anyone)
4. Hero
5. The Incredibles

Hey there!

Quick Links

Top 5 of the year

Comments